CountedIn vs Acuity Scheduling: Real Credit Tracking vs Package Codes

Quick Comparison

The Core Difference: Scheduling vs Credit Tracking

Acuity Scheduling (now part of Squarespace) is an appointment scheduling tool. It’s great at what it does — letting clients book time slots, managing availability, sending reminders, and processing payments at booking.

CountedIn is a session credit tracking tool. It tracks how many sessions a client has purchased, used, and has remaining, with a dashboard, alerts, and client visibility.

These overlap slightly (Acuity has “packages,” CountedIn has clients who book sessions), but they solve fundamentally different problems.

Acuity’s “Package” Problem

Acuity offers something called package codes. Here’s how they work:

1. You create a package (e.g., “10 Session Pack - $500”)
2. Client purchases the package
3. Acuity generates a discount code
4. Client uses the code when booking appointments to “redeem” sessions
5. The code expires after the set number of uses

This sounds like session credit tracking. It is not.

What’s Wrong with Package Codes

Clients must remember and use a code. Every time a client books, they need to enter their package code. If they forget, they get charged full price for the session. If they lose the code, they’re stuck messaging you to look it up.

No credit balance visibility. There’s no clean dashboard showing a client “you have 6 of 10 sessions remaining.” The client has a code that works until it doesn’t. They don’t know how many uses are left unless they count manually.

No provider-side credit dashboard. As the professional, you can’t open Acuity and see a list of all clients with their remaining session counts. You’d need to look up each package code individually to check remaining uses.

No low credit alerts. Acuity doesn’t notify you when a client is getting low on package sessions. You find out when the code stops working — which might be when the client is standing in front of you expecting a session.

Tied to the booking flow. Package redemption only happens through the booking process. If a client doesn’t book through Acuity (maybe they text you, or it’s a recurring session you don’t re-book each week), the package doesn’t decrement. You’re back to manual tracking.

No bulk session logging. If you teach a group class where five clients attend and all have packages, you can’t log all five in one action. Each client’s session needs to go through the booking/redemption flow individually.

The Fundamental Issue

Acuity treats packages as discount codes applied to bookings. CountedIn treats session credits as a first-class concept — tracked, displayed, alerted on, and managed through a purpose-built system.

This isn’t a small difference. It’s the difference between a feature tacked onto a scheduling tool and a product built around credit tracking from day one.

Where Acuity Excels

Online Scheduling

Acuity is genuinely excellent at scheduling:

• Customizable booking pages with your branding
• Multiple appointment types with different durations and prices
• Buffer times between appointments
• Timezone detection for virtual sessions
• Calendar sync (Google, Outlook, iCloud)
• Automated email and SMS reminders
• Recurring appointment support
• Intake forms and questionnaires at booking

If scheduling is your primary problem — clients need to book time slots, and you need to manage availability — Acuity is one of the best tools available.

Payment at Booking

Acuity can collect payment when a client books. This is great for reducing no-shows and ensuring you get paid. It integrates with Stripe, Square, and PayPal.

Squarespace Integration

If your website is on Squarespace, Acuity integrates seamlessly. Embed your booking page directly on your site with consistent branding.

Clean Interface

Acuity has a clean, modern interface that’s pleasant to use. The booking page clients see is customizable and professional.

The Workflow Disconnect

Here’s where things break down for session-based professionals using Acuity:

Typical Trainer/Teacher Workflow

1. Client buys a 10-session package
2. Client comes for session 1 — you log it
3. Client comes for session 2 — you log it
4. …
5. Client is at session 8 — you want to remind them to buy their next package
6. Client finishes session 10 — seamless transition to next package

What This Looks Like in Acuity

1. Client buys a package on Acuity, gets a code
2. Client books session 1 using the code (if they remember it)
3. Client books session 2 — oops, they forgot the code, gets charged full price, you have to issue a refund
4. Client has a recurring Tuesday slot — doesn’t rebook through Acuity each week, code isn’t redeemed, your tracking is off
5. You have no idea the client is at session 8 because there’s no credit dashboard
6. Client’s code stops working mid-booking, they message you confused, you scramble to figure out what happened

What This Looks Like in CountedIn

1. Client buys a 10-session package, you set it up in CountedIn
2. Client comes for session 1, you tap once to log it. Balance: 9
3. Client comes for session 2, you tap once. Balance: 8
4. All sessions logged with one tap, regardless of how they were booked
5. At session 8, CountedIn alerts you that the client is running low
6. You reach out, client buys next package, zero disruption

The difference is night and day.

Pricing Breakdown

Solo Practitioner

Acuity’s Emerging plan is cheaper, but it doesn’t actually track session credits — it provides package codes. And it keeps Acuity branding on your booking page. The Growing plan at $27/month removes branding but still lacks real credit tracking.

Studio Plan Comparison

At the same price point, you’re choosing between real session credit tracking (CountedIn) or robust scheduling (Acuity). Neither does the other’s job well.

Can You Use Both?

Yes, and some professionals do. The workflow:

• Acuity handles scheduling, booking, and appointment reminders
• CountedIn handles session credit tracking, package management, and client balance visibility

This dual setup means:

• Clients book through Acuity (or however you currently schedule)
• You log sessions in CountedIn after they happen (one tap)
• CountedIn tracks credits, sends low-credit alerts, and gives clients their portal
• No package codes, no redemption workflow, no lost codes

At $29/mo (CountedIn) + $16/mo (Acuity) = $45/month, this is less than many all-in-one platforms and gives you best-in-class tools for each job.

The “Acuity Does Packages, That’s Enough” Objection

Some professionals look at Acuity’s package feature and think it’s sufficient. Before deciding, ask yourself:

• Can you see all clients’ remaining credits in one view? (No)
• Do clients know their balance without asking you? (Not really)
• Are you alerted when a client is running low? (No)
• Can you log a session without going through the booking flow? (No)
• Can you handle group sessions efficiently? (Not well)
• Can you track clients who don’t book through Acuity? (No)

If you sell session packages and any of these matter to you, Acuity’s package codes aren’t enough.

Who Should Choose Acuity

Choose Acuity if you:

• Need a scheduling and booking system as your primary tool
• Run an appointment-based business (not package/credit-based)
• Want clients to self-book available time slots
• Need intake forms and questionnaires at booking
• Have a Squarespace website and want native integration
• Don’t sell session packages (or sell them rarely)
• Charge per appointment, not per package

Who Should Choose CountedIn

Choose CountedIn if you:

• Sell sessions as packages or credits
• Need to track remaining sessions for every client
• Want clients to see their balance via a simple link
• Need automatic low-credit alerts
• Log sessions manually (not through a booking flow)
• Teach groups alongside private sessions
• Want a dedicated credit dashboard for your entire client base
• Are frustrated with Acuity’s package code limitations

The Bottom Line

Acuity is an outstanding scheduling tool. If your primary need is managing appointment bookings, it’s one of the best.

But scheduling and session credit tracking are different problems. Acuity’s package codes are a basic add-on to a scheduling product, not a real credit tracking system. They require clients to remember codes, offer no balance visibility, provide no alerts, and break down for non-booking session logging.

CountedIn is purpose-built for session credit tracking. If you sell session packages — whether you also need scheduling or not — CountedIn gives you the credit management that Acuity’s package codes simply cannot.

Ready for real session credit tracking?

Start your 14-day free trial at Start your free trial — no credit card required.